Jobs to Be Done - critical summary review

Ulwick challenges the conventional, ideas-first approach to innovation, often reliant on guesswork, hunches, or post-rationalized user stories. Instead, he argues for a disciplined, science-backed method grounded in identifying what customers are truly trying to achieve, before offering solutions. Innovation, he insists, should not be an experiment; it should be a process of uncovering unmet needs and systematically addressing them.

At the heart of the book is Ulwick’s proprietary framework, the Outcome-Driven Innovation (ODI). This isn’t a loose collection of principles; it’s a rigorously detailed process with 84 steps that allow teams to identify, quantify, and prioritize customer needs, enabling smarter product design and go-to-market strategy.

One of the standout contributions in this book is the Jobs-to-be-Done (JTBD) Growth Strategy Matrix, a practical and clarifying tool for mapping market opportunities. Ulwick uses this matrix to integrate and simplify the work of Clayton Christensen, his mentor and inspiration, and reconcile it with its critiques and alternatives.

Rethinking innovation with Outcome-Driven Strategies

The "ideas-first" approach is widely practiced and often involves generating a multitude of product or service ideas, which are then tested with customers to assess how well they address perceived needs. This method, while popular, is flawed for several reasons. First, it assumes that generating a large number of ideas increases the likelihood of discovering a breakthrough solution, but it ignores the complexity of customer needs.

Second, the evaluation and filtering processes used in “ideas-first” methods often fail, because they are based on intuition or incomplete data. Lastly, customers typically cannot specify the solutions they want, which makes it unwise to rely on them for developing new ideas. Despite its popularity and academic endorsement, the "ideas-first" approach is prone to failure, because it fails to ground innovation in a clear and accurate understanding of customer needs.

The "needs-first" approach attempts to remedy this by focusing on identifying customer needs, before developing solutions. This approach, while not fundamentally flawed, is often poorly executed. Ulwick highlights that many companies, despite recognizing the importance of addressing customer needs, struggle with defining and categorizing them properly. A common issue is that different stakeholders within a company may have conflicting views on what constitutes a customer need, and often, a lack of a common language or framework to define and prioritize these needs leads to fragmented efforts.

Ulwick’s ODI process addresses these shortcomings by utilizing the JTBD framework. This framework redefines innovation by categorizing customer needs into distinct types, such as core functional jobs, emotional and social jobs, and consumption chain jobs, each with its own set of measurable outcomes. By focusing on the job customers are trying to complete, rather than on product solutions or customer preferences, companies can gain a clearer, more structured understanding of the customer’s needs.

Ulwick asserts that understanding the complete set of customer needs, through the framework of JTBD, can drastically improve decision-making across product development, marketing, and customer experience. By mapping out these needs and evaluating solutions based on how well they help customers achieve their desired outcomes, companies can significantly increase their chances of success in the marketplace. With this data-driven approach, innovation becomes a science, not a game of chance.

Choosing the right growth strategy

Once it has identified all customer needs, a company must determine which of those needs are underserved or overserved, and assess which customer segments exhibit these characteristics. This segmentation helps companies decide how to target these groups effectively. Ulwick emphasizes that the success of new products or services in the marketplace is largely determined by their ability to help customers get a job done more effectively or cheaply. This leads to the development of the JTBD Growth Strategy Matrix, a framework that categorizes growth strategies into five key approaches: differentiated, dominant, disruptive, discrete, and sustaining strategies.

The matrix suggests that businesses must understand whether customers are underserved or overserved, as this will influence which strategy they should adopt. Each of these five strategies serves specific customer segments and market situations. A differentiated strategy, for example, works best for underserved customers willing to pay a premium for better performance, while a dominant strategy appeals to all consumers, offering a solution that is both cheaper and better.

Disruptive strategies, on the other hand, cater to overserved customers or nonconsumers, providing a cheaper, though less effective, alternative to existing solutions. A discrete strategy targets specific, restricted situations where customers are willing to pay higher prices for a product or service due to limited alternatives, while a sustaining strategy focuses on making incremental improvements to existing products, which is more suitable for companies already entrenched in the market.

Ulwick discusses how businesses can use this matrix to predict and influence the success or failure of new products. He notes that a company must thoroughly understand its target market's customer segments and their needs before deciding on a growth strategy. This is where the Outcome-Based Segmentation (OBS) methodology, part of the ODI process, becomes crucial. By segmenting the market based on prioritized customer outcomes, companies can ensure they are targeting the right segments with the appropriate strategy.

A data-backed path to predictable success

The central idea of the book is that companies must focus on understanding and meeting the specific jobs customers are trying to get done, rather than relying on vague qualitative insights or traditional approaches that often lead to unpredictable results. Ulwick introduces ODI as a comprehensive process designed to enhance innovation success by aligning products and services with customer-defined performance metrics.

ODI begins with defining the customer in a way that simplifies and clarifies who the true target audience is, focusing on three key customer types: the core job executor (the primary user), the product lifecycle support team (those who maintain and support the product), and the purchase decision maker (those who decide on the purchase). By analyzing the needs and insights from these customer types, companies can develop more efficient and effective solutions. The next crucial step is to define the job-to-be-done, which is the core function the customer wants to complete, making sure not to define it too narrowly or too broadly.

Once the job is defined, companies map out the customer’s desired outcomes. These outcomes are essential for understanding customer needs at a granular level and are used to create a detailed "job map" that outlines all the steps in the customer’s process. Ulwick explains that each step in this job map can reveal insights into areas where the customer is either underserved or overserved by current solutions, pointing to potential innovation opportunities.

The next step, in the ODI process, involves uncovering these segments of opportunity, where unmet needs create the potential for new products or improvements. Using quantitative methods, such as surveys and factor analysis, ODI helps identify distinct market segments based on their unmet needs, rather than traditional demographic data. This segmentation reveals which groups are underserved and what specific outcomes they desire. Companies can then craft a value proposition that targets these underserved needs, positioning their products and services in a way that directly addresses these gaps.

A major component of the ODI process is competitive analysis, which focuses on understanding how well competing solutions fulfill customer-defined outcomes. This approach allows companies to identify where they can outperform competitors and meet needs more effectively, thereby gaining a competitive advantage. The final step in the process is formulating the innovation strategy. With the insights gained from ODI, companies can confidently decide which market segments to target, what unmet needs to address, and how to prioritize innovation efforts.

What customers really want: lessons from ODI success stories

In these case studies, the author demonstrates how the ODI methodology helps identify hidden growth opportunities by focusing on the “job” customers are trying to accomplish and the outcomes they seek, often misaligned with current market offerings. Ulwick shows how companies like Microsoft, Kroll Ontrack, Arm & Hammer, Bosch, Abbott Medical Optics, and Hussmann used ODI to uncover unmet needs, innovate effectively, and achieve significant improvements in customer satisfaction, market share, and revenue.

For example, Microsoft, facing declining renewals for its Software Assurance offering, used ODI to understand the complete customer job, from acquisition to disposal. By identifying underserved needs and bundling existing solutions more strategically, Microsoft improved its value proposition, boosting satisfaction and renewal rates even before a full product overhaul.

Kroll Ontrack, entering the nascent electronic document discovery market, lacked a clear strategy due to clients’ uncertainty about their needs. ODI revealed the desired outcomes of legal professionals, leading to innovations like the Harvester tool, which streamlined discovery and positioned Kroll as a market leader. Arm & Hammer shifted from emphasizing nutritional ingredients to focusing on dairy producers’ broader goal of herd productivity.

Bosch, seeking differentiation in the competitive circular saw market, identified overlooked segments with specific needs around tool handling. The resulting CS20 circular saw addressed these needs, earning market share and customer loyalty without raising costs. Abbott Medical Optics, once offering undifferentiated services, used ODI to redesign its approach for materials managers. By focusing on outcomes in the lens replenishment process, AMO adopted a relationship-driven service model that increased loyalty and industry recognition.

Hussmann’s LED lighting division had initially prioritized technology over customer needs. ODI helped the company address practical merchandising outcomes, resulting in the successful EcoShine system, which accelerated market adoption and revenue growth. Across these examples, ODI proves effective by shifting innovation away from product features and toward the outcomes that matter most to customers. By understanding these outcomes and segmenting markets accordingly, businesses can deliver more relevant, impactful solutions and achieve sustained growth.

Transforming organizations with ODI

The core concept revolves around creating an ODI competency within an organization, which emphasizes understanding and addressing customer needs from a functional and emotional perspective. To adopt this mindset, organizations should have an internal ODI Practitioner for each business unit, who can guide cross-functional teams in applying JTBD theory through a structured approach.

The process begins with educating a core group of employees on the principles of JTBD, followed by rigorous research to gather valuable customer insights through qualitative and quantitative methods. The ultimate goal is to align innovation efforts with clear, customer-defined outcomes, ensuring that products and services are developed to meet these needs better than existing alternatives.

The transformation into an Outcome-Driven Organization is presented as a phased process. In Phase I, cross-functional product teams engage in a two-day workshop where they gain insights into customer jobs, including both functional and emotional aspects, using a unique JTBD lens. This phase helps the team understand key customer needs and job maps, which serve as stable, long-term guides for future innovation.

Phase II focuses on expanding these insights through quantitative research, including surveys of a large, representative customer base. The resulting data is analyzed to identify hidden market opportunities and guide product and market strategy decisions. Phase III shifts the focus to training employees across the organization on how to apply these insights to drive actionable strategies in marketing, sales, product development, and other areas of the business. This phase is vital because it equips the team with the tools to make data-driven decisions that foster long-term growth.

Furthermore, Ulwick mentions the significance of aligning JTBD with existing organizational processes, such as Six Sigma or market research teams, to maximize efficiency and effectiveness. He explains that forming an internal "Innovation Center of Excellence," composed of trained ODI Practitioners, can accelerate the adoption of JTBD and guide the company through the transformation into an outcome-driven organization.

Ulwick also elaborates on the language of JTBD, providing a set of terms and definitions that enable clearer communication and understanding within the organization. These terms include "customer needs," "desired outcomes," "job maps," and different types of innovation strategies, all of which help to provide a common language for innovation.

The text emphasizes that innovation should be driven by customer needs rather than just creative brainstorming or product ideation. By applying JTBD, companies can not only improve the relevance of their products but also identify new market opportunities and strategic directions. Ulwick provides frameworks, such as the JTBD Growth Strategy Matrix, which helps organizations understand when to apply different innovation strategies based on the level of market need and competition.

Final notes

Ulwick’s book focuses on transforming organizations by using the ODI process, which is rooted in the JTBD framework. Unlike traditional "ideas-first" innovation methods, which often fail because they don't accurately address customer needs, ODI focuses on identifying customer jobs and their desired outcomes, before developing solutions.

By understanding both functional and emotional needs, companies can create better products and strategies. Ulwick emphasizes that innovation should be based on data-driven insights, guiding companies to use JTBD to uncover underserved market segments, prioritize customer needs, and apply the right growth strategies for sustained success.

12min tip

“The Trading Game,” by Gary Stevenson, is a raw, unfiltered look at the dark heart of the trading world, where one man’s rise to the top leads to a thrilling moral reckoning. If you’re curious about the real-life drama behind multi-billion-dollar deals and the price of success, this is the book you can’t miss.